allboardgames.com
I Say, Holmes! (second Edition) box art
2014 Ranked #21,685

I Say, Holmes! (second Edition)

Use clues and contradictions to deduce hidden information.

Card Game Deduction Memory Open Drafting

Players

3-8

Play time

30-45 min

Age

13+

Complexity

1.58/5

Rating

5.52

Harder to teach Highly interactive Deep strategy

Overview

At a glance

Is this game right for my group?

ABG editorial scores on a 1–5 scale.

Teachability 2.4/5

Harder to teach

Replay value 4.0/5

High replayability

Interaction 3.7/5

Highly interactive

Player scaling 4.1/5

Scales well

Strategic depth 4.7/5

Deep strategy

See all 5 specifications

How it plays

How does it play?

I Say, Holmes! is a card game based on the classic adventures of Sherlock Holmes by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle.

Core mechanisms

Key systems that shape the decisions players make.

Read the full game description

I Say, Holmes! is a card game based on the classic adventures of Sherlock Holmes by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. As observers on Holmes’ current case, you will play a variety of cards to push the case forward, creating the story as Holmes and Watson attempt to arrest the villain; the only problem is that at least one of you is acting as a double agent, endeavoring to assist the villains as they try to slip from the Great Detective's grasp. This new version of I Say, Holmes! features completely new custom art created by Clark Miller (Darkest Night, Trieste) showcased on 125 playing cards, alongside custom-shaped, laser-cut counters; we’ve brought all of our expertise to bear on making I Say, Holmes! into one of our most stunningly beautiful game yet.

Browse all classifications

Shopping

Where to buy

No verified retailer offers are available yet. The references below may still help you continue your search.

Unverified shopping references

Editions

Language and publisher variants currently recorded in the catalog.

Edition Year Language Publisher / Region
No editions imported yet.

Player resources

Rulebooks, player aids, FAQs, and solo resources.

No files imported yet.

Game and edition data

All specifications (5)

Play and group

Players
3–8
Best with
4–8
Play time
30–45 min
Age
13+
Complexity
1.6/5
Credits and catalog connections

Credits

Designers

2
Alan Emrich Roger Heyworth

Artists

1
Clark Miller

Publishers

1
Victory Point Games

Linked items

No published linked games yet.